There's No Better Place to Share a Slice

Our Story

Built on Tradition, Served with Heart

Papa's Pizza started with a simple idea: make pizza the way it's supposed to be made — with quality ingredients, real dough stretched by hand, and a recipe that's been passed down for generations.

Now, we're proud to be Farmingdale's neighborhood pizzeria. Every pie that comes out of our oven carries the same care and attention we'd give our own family. Whether you're grabbing a quick dinner or planning a gathering, we want you to taste the difference that genuine craft makes.